What Is Unit Economics? CAC, LTV and Contribution Margin Explained

On 3 April 1860 a rider left the town of St. Joseph, Missouri, heading west with a leather mail pouch. The Pony Express had begun. Letters were to travel roughly 3,100 kilometres to Sacramento, California, carried by riders who changed horses from station to station. The owners, Russell, Majors and Waddell, bought more than 400 horses at an average of about USD 200 each and hired around 80 riders.
The price was set to match the speed: USD 5 for a half-ounce letter. Ordinary postage was 2 cents, so the Pony Express charged 250 times the price of an ordinary letter. The rate later fell to USD 2.50, and by July 1861 to USD 1.
The service lasted 18 months. On 24 October 1861 the transcontinental telegraph line was completed, and two days later the Pony Express announced its closure. According to the figures compiled by Wikipedia, in that time the company carried about 35,000 letters, took in USD 90,000 and lost USD 200,000.
A rough calculation with those figures makes the picture clear. Average revenue per letter comes to around USD 2.60. If costs were revenue plus the loss, roughly USD 290,000, the cost per letter was over USD 8. Even a price 250 times that of ordinary post did not cover the cost of a single letter. Carrying more letters would not have shrunk the loss; it would have grown it.
What is unit economics?
Unit economics compares the money you make from a single customer, or a single sale, with the variable cost of serving that customer. Tom Blomfield, a Y Combinator partner and co-founder of Monzo, puts it in its simplest form in YC's Startup School lecture: revenue per customer minus the variable or incremental cost of serving that customer.
Blomfield draws the line clearly as well: costs that would not change if your customer base doubled or tripled, such as engineering salaries or the rent on your head office, do not belong in unit economics. They are deducted at the end. Unit economics looks at the costs that grow with the number of customers.
Contribution margin: what does each customer leave behind?
What remains when you take variable costs away from revenue is that customer's contribution margin. In Blomfield's Monzo example the variable costs were concrete: the plastic cards sent out new and as replacements for lost ones, every contact with customer service, fraud on the account and payment fees. Monzo tracked these per customer, so it could see which groups of customers made money and which lost it.
Customer acquisition cost (CAC): measure it channel by channel
Customer acquisition cost is what you spend to win a customer. Blomfield has two warnings. First, measure it channel by channel: record where every user came from, and keep that record forever, because you will want to see how those customers behave months later. Second, calculate the cost against a customer who stays and pays, not against a sign-up. If most sign-ups can vanish in the first week, the real question is not what a sign-up costs you but what a lasting customer costs you.
Lifetime value (LTV): a cheap customer can turn out expensive
Lifetime value is the total contribution margin a customer leaves while they stay with you. As Blomfield tells it, Monzo had a money-saving blog that sent it customers very cheaply. The acquisition cost looked excellent, but the customers from that channel loaded money onto their cards, went abroad and took cash out of ATMs, costing the company more than they brought in. Their lifetime value was negative. Monzo closed the channel even though its acquisition cost looked good. We covered how to measure customer loss in What Is Customer Churn?; lifetime value is that loss expressed in money.
Payback period: how many months until you get your money back?
The payback period is customer acquisition cost divided by monthly contribution margin. If winning a customer costs you 300 lira and that customer leaves you 25 lira of contribution each month, you get your money back in 12 months. If the average customer stays eight months, every new customer is making you a little poorer. The longer the payback period, the more cash growth needs to bridge the gap; build it into your runway calculation.
Do not scale negative unit economics
This is Blomfield's clearest warning: scaling negative unit economics is very dangerous. He explains that Monzo's unit economics were negative in its early years and that it grew its customer numbers before fixing them; his advice is to turn unit economics positive before you grow. The Pony Express says the same thing: if every letter loses money, more letters mean more losses.

Margin: a word that means edge
The business word margin comes from the Latin margo, meaning edge, border, the brink of something. Its financial sense settled as the difference between the selling price and the cost of production. The root is a useful reminder: the margin is the strip at the edge that a business walks along. If the strip is wide, growth carries you safely; if it is narrowing, every step brings you closer to the brink.

Nature does not leap
The English economist Alfred Marshall placed a single Latin sentence at the head of the preface to the first edition of his Principles of Economics, published in 1890:
"Natura non facit saltum."
Nature does not make leaps. Nor does a business that loses money on one customer leap into profit on thousands of them. Is every customer you win today leaving you money, or are you growing your losses as you grow?
To plan the cash side of growth, Before the Cash Runs Out: How to Manage Runway and Burn Rate is worth a read.


