# What Is Direct-to-Consumer Selling? What Cutting Out the Middleman Gains and Costs

- URL: https://girisimcikafasi.com/en/blog/what-is-direct-to-consumer-dtc/
- Published: 2026-11-21
- Updated: 2026-11-21
- Category: Marketing and distribution
- Publisher: Girişimci Kafası

Aaron Montgomery Ward worked as a clerk in a country store in Michigan, then travelled for wholesale dry-goods houses in Chicago. On the road he kept seeing the same thing: farmers bought everything from the single store in town. The cost of bringing goods out from the city was added to the price, and purchases went on credit until the harvest came in.

Ward's first stock was destroyed in the Great Chicago Fire. He did not give up: in August 1872, with two fellow employees and USD 1,600 of capital, he founded Montgomery Ward & Company. He rented a small room on North Clark Street and printed a list of 163 products on a single sheet. Farmers would choose from the list and send their order by post. There was no store in town in between.

Ward's offer had no haggling and no credit. The price was the price. He built trust with another promise instead: anyone who was not satisfied would get their money back. According to the Chicago History Museum, that promise was an industry first. The list grew to 32 pages in 1874 and to 152 pages with 3,000 items in 1876. In 1946 the Grolier Club exhibited the Ward catalogue, alongside Webster's dictionary, among the 100 books that most influenced American life.

The model now called direct-to-consumer, or DTC, is a descendant of that single-sheet list. You cut out the middleman and keep both the price and the customer. But Ward's story also has an ending, and for DTC brands it is the most instructive part.

## What does cutting out the middleman give you?

### Margin and control of price

The share that would have gone to the store, the wholesaler or the marketplace stays with you. You can use that money to lower the price or to improve the product. You decide on which shelf, and at what discount, your price appears.

### A direct relationship with the customer

You see who buys, what they send back and when they return. A brand that sells through stores often never learns any of this. Ward's money-back promise grew out of that relationship too: with no shop in between, only he could give the guarantee.

## The hidden bill of DTC

A 2022 analysis by Rob Litterst at The Hustle sums up why the DTC wave struggled under three headings. According to Alex Kantrowitz, whom Litterst cites, the model was promising as long as costs stayed low. Brands had been built on cheap Facebook advertising, ad targeting that tracked users, and low shipping costs.

### The shop's rent turns into the ad budget

According to the analysis, Facebook ad prices tripled in the two years before 2022. The share you no longer pay a middleman now goes to the platform to find customers. It also notes that Warby Parker went public with 13% brand awareness: people do not get to know a brand that is not on a shelf by themselves.

### You cannot manage spending you cannot measure

With Apple's iOS 14.5 update, apps had to ask for permission to track users. According to an expert Litterst cites, Meta's ad attribution was off by 30% to 50% as a result. Brands spent more, often for worse results.

### Shipping, returns and capital

According to the analysis, the cost of shipping a container from China to the US rose from USD 2,000 to USD 15,000 after the start of the pandemic. In DTC, shipping is your cost, and so is everything that comes back: the store does not absorb returns, you do. When interest rates rose, investors turned to profitable companies; Allbirds shares lost 63% of their value in 2022.

## When does DTC work?

- **When customers come back.** Litterst writes that Chewy can carry its costs because the lifetime value of its customers is predictable. On a one-off purchase, the cost of acquiring a customer chokes you; on repeat purchases it spreads out. We looked at ways to strengthen this in [What Is a Loyalty Programme?](https://girisimcikafasi.com/en/blog/what-is-a-loyalty-programme/)
- **When you do not depend on a single channel.** One of the analysis's suggestions is to go beyond Meta, so that a change in one platform's prices or rules does not shake your whole business.
- **When you do not rule out the physical world.** One of the paths Litterst lists is opening physical stores. Cutting out the middleman does not mean withdrawing from every place where customers see you.

## Retail, the middleman and the middleman's return

The Turkish word for retail, perakende, comes from the Persian parâgande, meaning "dispersed, scattered". The retailer is the one who disperses goods that arrive wholesale. In English, removing the middleman is called disintermediation; the term was first used in banking, for savers who took their deposits out of banks and invested directly. It also has an opposite: reintermediation, the middleman's return. The internet did not erase intermediaries; it put new ones in their place.

Montgomery Ward became a living example of that cycle. The company that bypassed the middleman with its catalogue opened its first store in 1926 and had 531 stores by 1929. In 1985 it closed its catalogue business after 113 years; on 28 December 2000 it announced it would close its remaining stores as well. Selling directly was not an advantage won once and kept forever; it was a relationship that had to be won again in every generation.

## Where the product touches the customer

In My Life and Work, published in 1922 and written with Samuel Crowther, Henry Ford puts it like this:

> "The cutting edge of merchandising is the point where the product touches the consumer."

DTC hands you that point, but also the whole cost of the road that leads to it. Where does your product touch the customer, and whom do you pay, and how much, to reach that point?

*If you are curious about the other model that brings buyers and sellers together, [What Is a Marketplace Business Model?](https://girisimcikafasi.com/en/blog/what-is-a-marketplace-business-model/) is worth a read.*
